FREE COMFORT-GRIP HANDLE WITH EVERY CUP
The Splitflask guide
Owala vs Simple Modern: Which Water Bottle Should You Buy?
The short answer
Owala or Simple Modern? Owala's FreeSip wins on its two-way sip lid for cold water. Simple Modern's Trek wins on price, hot drinks and an all-dishwasher-safe build. Here's how to choose, and when neither is the right fit.
Short answer: pick the Owala FreeSip if you mostly drink cold water and want that famous two-way lid (straw sip or tilt-and-swig). Pick the Simple Modern Trek if you want a cheaper, cup-holder-friendly 40 oz tumbler that can also take hot drinks and goes in the dishwasher. And if your real problem is that you drink coffee and water every day, neither one solves it by itself (more on that below).
We checked every spec below on Owala's and Simple Modern's own websites in November 2026. Prices and colors change often, so confirm on the brand site before you buy.
The quick comparison
| Owala FreeSip | Simple Modern Trek (40 oz) | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Water bottle with sip/swig lid | Tumbler with handle and straw lid |
| Sizes listed | 24, 32 and 40 oz | 40 oz |
| Price we saw | $34.99 (24 oz) | $27.99 |
| Hot drinks? | No. Owala says not for hot, carbonated or perishable liquids | Yes. Simple Modern claims hot for 12 hrs, cold for 24 hrs |
| Cold claim | 24 hours cold | 24 hours cold |
| Dishwasher | Lid top-rack safe; cup technically safe, but Owala strongly recommends hand-washing | Tumbler, lid and straw top-rack dishwasher safe |
| Warranty | Limited lifetime (excludes accidents, misuse, normal wear) | Limited lifetime for manufacturer's defects |
Sources: Owala FreeSip product page, Owala FAQ, Simple Modern Trek product page.
Wait, isn't this a bottle vs a tumbler?
Yes, and that's the honest truth of most "Owala vs Simple Modern" searches. The two bestsellers people compare are different shapes: Owala's hero is the FreeSip bottle, and Simple Modern's hero is the Trek tumbler. Both brands also make the other shape (Owala has its own tumblers, which its FAQ says can hold cold, carbonated and hot drinks; Simple Modern makes bottles too). So start with the shape that fits your day, then pick the brand.
- Bottle = goes in a bag, tips over without drama, carries with a loop.
- Tumbler with handle = lives in a cup holder or on a desk, holds more, easier to fill with ice.
Still torn on shape? Our tumbler vs water bottle guide walks through it.
Where Owala wins
The lid
The FreeSip lid is the whole reason Owala got famous: sip upright through the built-in straw, or tilt it back and swig from the spout. It also locks. If you chug water at the gym and sip it at your desk, that's a genuinely useful lid.
Bag-friendly
A lockable bottle is simply easier to throw in a tote or gym bag than a 40 oz handle tumbler.
Where it falls short
It's a cold-only bottle. Owala's own FAQ says the stainless steel FreeSip is "not for use with hot, carbonated, or perishable liquids." So no morning coffee, no sparkling water, no protein shake. If you want coffee in an Owala, you need one of their tumblers instead. We cover the details in can you put coffee in an Owala?
Where Simple Modern wins
Price
At $27.99 for 40 oz when we checked, the Trek costs less than a 24 oz FreeSip and holds a lot more.
Hot and cold
Simple Modern claims the Trek keeps drinks hot for 12 hours and cold for 24. That makes it the more flexible pick if you want one cup for coffee in the morning and ice water in the afternoon (just not both at once). More in can you put coffee in a Simple Modern?
Easy cleanup
Tumbler, lid and straw are all top-rack dishwasher safe, per Simple Modern. Owala's cup is technically dishwasher safe but Owala strongly recommends hand-washing it.
Where it falls short
A straw-lid tumbler is not a bag bottle. It's made for the cup holder and the desk, not for tossing sideways into a backpack.
Who should buy which
- Buy the Owala FreeSip if: you drink mostly cold water, carry it in a bag, and love a sip-or-swig lid.
- Buy the Simple Modern Trek if: you want the most ounces for the money, drive a lot, want hot-or-cold flexibility, and like a dishwasher.
- Buy neither if: you're really trying to carry two different drinks. Read on.
The split-personality problem neither one solves
Here's the morning a lot of us actually have: hot coffee in one hand, a water bottle in the other, keys in your teeth. Owala and Simple Modern are both one-drink containers. Even the hot-capable ones hold coffee or water, not coffee and water.
That's the job the Splitflask 30oz Dual-Chamber Tumbler ($54.99) was designed for. It has two sealed 15 oz chambers with independent vacuum insulation: a spout for your hot drink on one side, a straw for your cold drink on the other. It's made of food-grade 18/8 stainless steel, has leak-resistant seals when both lids are closed correctly, and is designed for most standard cup holders (fit varies by car). It's patented, and it was designed by a NICU nurse who was tired of juggling two drink containers.
Honest trade-offs: each side holds 15 oz, so if you want one giant 40 oz of ice water, a Trek holds more in a single drink. And Splitflask costs more than either of these. Fill both sides with water and you get a 30 oz total. It's a better buy only if you really do carry two drinks.
Want to see how it compares to other big names? See the best Stanley alternatives, Owala vs Stanley and Simple Modern vs Stanley.
FAQ
Is Owala better than Simple Modern?
Not across the board. Owala's FreeSip has the more loved lid for cold water. Simple Modern's Trek is cheaper, holds more and handles hot drinks. "Better" depends on whether you carry a bottle in a bag or a tumbler in your car.
Can you put coffee in an Owala FreeSip?
No. Owala says the stainless steel FreeSip should not be used for hot, carbonated or perishable liquids. Its tumblers are the Owala option for hot drinks.
Is Simple Modern dishwasher safe?
For the Trek tumbler, yes: Simple Modern says the tumbler, lid and straw are top-rack dishwasher safe.
Which one fits a cup holder?
Simple Modern describes the Trek's tapered shape as made for cup holders. The FreeSip is a bottle, so fit depends on the size you pick and your car.
What if I want coffee and water in one cup?
Neither does that. A dual-chamber tumbler like Splitflask keeps a hot drink and a cold drink in separate sealed sides.
The bottom line
Cold water, bag carry, great lid: Owala. Big, cheap, hot-or-cold, dishwasher-friendly: Simple Modern. Coffee and water every single day: skip the either/or and get both in one Splitflask.